Retiring Predisposition
View PhotoWe took two cameras, my Canon 20D and Chris's K100 Pentax, and two zooms each: for the Canon the 10-22 and 24-105; for the Pentax the 16-45 and 50-200. Since the K100 has image stabilization built into the body, and the 24-105 has Canon's IS, we did without tripods. Results were good, I think. You can see my photos at my April gallery, Chris's at hers. True, in my case what came out of the camera were mostly postcards; but I was there as a tourist, not a photo-Basho.
The K100 is Chris's only DSLR, but I have a Pentax K10 with a nice range of Limited lenses. Why didn't I take that kit instead of the older and in most ways less capable Canon 20D? Briefly, this wasn't a photo expedition. I felt I needed something that would give me good results with minimal tsuris, though not necessarily the kind of painfully-sharp, B&W-in-color look I've mentioned in connection with the K10. So I picked the DSLR I'd always pick if asked to do a routine job of work: the Canon with 24-105 f/4L IS zoom. I used that combination 90% of the time, only falling back on the very wide 10-22 for the occasional odd shot.
The 24-105 is a marvel. No kidding. It's not a heavy lens by Canon pro standards, but it's built like a brick shithouse, well sealed, smooth to zoom and focus, and sharp all over. There's a bit of barrel distortion at the wide end, and if you correct for that in Photoshop you lose a bit of the wideness, but that's acceptable to me. The bokeh isn't great, but I seldom use OOF backgrounds, so I can live with it. The f/4 limit sometimes had me shooting at ISO 1600, but with the 20D that was tolerable.
You can see what all those but's are adding up to: a literally professional package. Pros go out to get a good-enough picture, one they can sell. If they come back with something that's better than good, whoopee -- but they have to come back with something, and compromise is inevitable. Of course there were photos I'd rather have made with a Pentax Limited prime, and the less-mellifluous Pentax sensor, and a tripod, but those will have to wait till I'm well and truly retired.